Bitcoin falls, Saylor highlights STRC dividends
Summarize this article with:

Bitcoin was trading at $64,428 on Saturday, down 21.2% month-over-month. At the same time, Michael Saylor highlighted the performance of STRC, Strategy’s dividend preferred stock, to highlight its resilience in the face of the crypto fall. His chart shows exact numbers. However, a comparison period spoils the picture somewhat: over three months, bitcoin does better than STRC.

Despite Bitcoin's fall, Michael Saylor defends STRC dividends, showing his confidence in Strategy's financial strategy.

In brief

  • Bitcoin lost 21.2% month-on-month and 32.2% year-over-year, according to market data on Saturday.
  • STRC shows a return of 1% over one month, including dividends, and 13.4% over one year, compared to a loss of 29.8% for bitcoin.
  • Over three months, the trend is reversed: bitcoin progresses by 8.7%, compared to 7.5% for STRC.

STRC resists the fall of bitcoin, but not over all periods

Michael Saylor’s publication is based on four periods of comparison. Over one week, STRC posted a return of 0.3%, while bitcoin fell 9.1%. Over one month, the preferred share yields 1%, including dividends, compared to a drop of 17.3% for the cryptocurrency. Over one year, the gap becomes even more impressive: +13.4% for STRC, compared to -29.8% for bitcoin.

On Saylor defends this performance with its usual formula: bitcoin represents digital capital, while Strategy transforms it into digital credit. He also points out that STRC’s price remained almost stable over a month and that dividends brought its total return to 1%.

However, the graph includes a fourth period that is less flattering to his argument. Over three months, bitcoin gained 8.7%, compared to only 7.5% for STRC. In other words, the product supposed to offer a more stable alternative does not systematically outperform bitcoin. Even in Saylor’s charts, first place is not guaranteed.

A 12% yield, which really finances the dividends?

STRC has an annualized dividend rate of 12%, but this remains variable. According to data published by Strategya share was worth $99.91 as of the close of November 13. At an unchanged rate, this represents approximately $12 in annual dividends per $100 of par value. Please note, however: this is not a guaranteed and immutable coupon.

But the essential question concerns the origin of this money.

As of November 8, Strategy had a dollar reserve of $4.77 billion, intended to cover dividends from its preferred stock and interest on its debt. The company also held $146.2 million in cash. Between November 2 and 8, it drew 21.1 million from this reserve to honor dividend payments.

STRC’s performance therefore does not directly depend on a rise in bitcoin. Strategy instead relies on a cash reserve, notably fueled by the sale of common shares. A mechanism which raises questions about its long-term viability. On November 12, economist Peter Schiff questioned the sustainability of this model.

Added to this concern is another threat. The same day, MSCI announced its intention to exclude Strategy from its global stock indices. Such a move could reduce institutional investor demand for the company’s shares.

Strategy faces $9.37 billion in unrealized losses

Behind STRC’s performance, Strategy’s situation also deserves a closer look. The company holds 850,364 bitcoins, acquired for a total amount of $64.16 billion.

At a price of 64,428 dollars per unit, this reserve is worth approximately 54.79 billion. The difference represents an unrealized loss of $9.37 billion. It remains theoretical as long as Strategy does not sell its bitcoins, but it illustrates the exposure of its balance sheet to market fluctuations.

Despite this pressure, Michael Saylor continues his accumulation strategy. Between November 2 and 8, Strategy purchased 1,036 bitcoins for $81.9 million. At the same time, it repurchased 1,887,464 STRC shares for $188.3 million, through sales of common stock.

In the end, Saylor’s chart tells part of the story, but not the whole story. STRC has actually held up better than bitcoin over certain periods, notably during the recent correction. However, its return is based on a financing mechanism which deserves as much attention as the dividend rate displayed.

For investors, the comparison should therefore not be limited to the most flattering percentages. We must also look at the sources of financing, the risks and the periods where bitcoin regains the advantage. After all, a 12% return is eye-catching, but you still need to know who pays the bill.

Maximize your Tremplin.io experience with our ‘Read to Earn’ program! For every article you read, earn points and access exclusive rewards. Sign up now and start earning benefits.

Similar Posts